← ALL ISSUESCHANCERY SIGNAL1 MIN READ
SUNDAY, OCTOBER 4, 2026
Chancery bars former general counsel’s advancement claim on unclean-hands grounds
Care One addresses unclean hands where counsel retained an advancement right he was instructed to extinguish; Superior Court certifies an insurance-recoupment question for interlocutory appeal.
The Signal
Unclean hands bars advancement where former general counsel retained a right he was instructed to extinguish
What happened
In its September 24 decision in In re Care One, LLC Advancement Litigation, the Court of Chancery concluded that Lugo’s advancement claim was barred by unclean hands because he knowingly left his client uninformed about an advancement right he had been instructed to extinguish but retained. Care One had taken exceptions only to the Senior Magistrate’s rejection of equitable estoppel and unclean hands. The court announced that judgment would be entered for Care One without reaching equitable estoppel.
Practice impact
The decision illustrates an unclean-hands defense directed at the continued existence of the advancement right itself. For general counsel and advancement practitioners, the relevant conduct is the lawyer’s nondisclosure of a retained right despite instructions to extinguish it; the court described the facts as unusual.
Read the opinion →Rulings Worth Knowing
Superior Court denies Rule 54(b) judgment but certifies $50 million recoupment dispute
What happened
In The Turner Corporation v. Lexington Insurance Company, the Superior Court denied the AIG insurers’ request for Rule 54(b) judgment on October 2 for lack of qualifying hardship but granted Rule 42 certification, finding a substantial issue and exceptional circumstances in the dispute over recoupment of $50 million in settlement advances under New York law.
Practice impact
The underlying ruling found no contractual right to recoupment, and the court’s decision on whether New York law permits recovery of a settlement payment made under an express reservation of rights was a first for a Delaware court. What to watch: whether the Delaware Supreme Court accepts the certified interlocutory appeal.
Read the source →Chancery Signal provides legal news, research, and informational content and does not provide legal advice.