CHANCERY SIGNAL
← ALL ISSUES
CHANCERY SIGNAL2 MIN READ

FRIDAY, OCTOBER 9, 2026

Supreme Court: missed audited-financials deadline put investors on inquiry notice

This issue addresses inquiry notice from missed audited financials, the scope of a tax gross-up definition, UPEPA relief on a defamation crossclaim, and patent indemnity and interest recovery.

The Signal

Signal53

Missed audited-financials deadline ends tolling through inquiry notice

What happened

In Cornice Ventures I LLC and Cornice Ventures II LLC v. Joshua Silberstein, the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed dismissal of the Thrasio investors' fraud claims as untimely. Thrasio's failure to deliver contractually required audited financial statements put Cornice on inquiry notice by April 2021, if not sooner. Cornice appealed only the timeliness ruling, and its suit was filed more than three years after that notice arose.

Practice impact

The decision identifies a missed audited-financials deadline as an inquiry-notice trigger, particularly when preceded by evasions over financial disclosure. The Court did not decide whether either asserted tolling doctrine was properly invoked: both would toll limitations only until inquiry notice. That distinction makes the reporting breach central to the limitations analysis without resolving the threshold availability of tolling.

Read the opinion →
Signal41

Seller cannot recover shareholders' liquidation taxes under gross-up definition

What happened

In its October 8 post-trial opinion in Longshot Holdings, Inc. v. Quaker Chemical Corporation, the Superior Court rejected Longshot's request for $1.4 million in additional tax gross-up damages. The court found that the MIPA's Gross-Up Amount definition referred only to Longshot, not its shareholders' liquidation taxes. Longshot proved neither breach nor damages; the court identified the non-party shareholders as those who lost money and attributed any injury to Longshot to its decision to indemnify them.

Practice impact

The court expected any anticipated post-closing gross-up adjustment for liquidation to be referenced in the MIPA. Its separate damages analysis distinguishes shareholder tax losses from injury to the seller entity, providing a second ground for rejecting recovery in this case. What to watch: the opinion will serve as final judgment unless the parties identify open issues by letter within five days.

Read the opinion →

Rulings Worth Knowing

Signal48

UPEPA covers internal-dispute speech; defamation crossclaim fails

What happened

In Sand Park Capital, LLC v. Lyrix Holdings LLC, the Superior Court granted Lyrix's UPEPA motion against Diamantis's defamation crossclaim for lack of specificity and under the absolute litigation privilege, stayed his amendment motion, required costs, reasonable attorneys' fees and litigation expenses, and denied punitive damages.

Practice impact

Reading UPEPA's protected categories disjunctively, the court did not require the speech to concern a matter of public concern and rejected the commercial-speech exception because the speech concerned an internal company dispute. Lyrix's fee-and-expense submission is due within 15 days, with Diamantis's response due 15 days later.

Read the source →
Signal70

Patent indemnity enforced, but interest-on-interest recovery reversed

What happened

In Gendreau v. Movora LLC, the Supreme Court upheld this MIPA's coverage of post-closing patent losses despite willful infringement, denied indemnification-enforcement fees, and remanded to add the $9.8 million license cost and full patent-litigation fees while removing prejudgment interest on loan-interest expense.

Practice impact

The September 24 decision enforces the agreement's allocation of post-closing liability without establishing a blanket rule validating every indemnity for willful misconduct. It also separates covered patent-litigation fees from fees incurred enforcing indemnification rights, which a general indemnity provision does not itself shift, and treats prejudgment interest on loan-interest expense as an impermissible double recovery.

Read the opinion →

Chancery Signal provides legal news, research, and informational content and does not provide legal advice.