CHANCERY SIGNAL
← ALL ISSUES
CHANCERY SIGNAL3 MIN READ

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2026

Supreme Court confirms case-specific discretion over inspection forum restrictions

Inspection conditions and officer-status requirements lead, with additional rulings on inquiry notice, investor contracts, tax gross-ups, UPEPA and indemnification.

The Signal

Signal54

Treppel factors do not exhaust the inspection forum-restriction inquiry

What happened

In the Wong Leung trust’s inspection dispute with Amazon, the Supreme Court affirmed Chancery’s judgment by order on October 13 for the reasons in its November 5, 2025 letter opinion. The Court rejected an argument that the forum-restriction inquiry must be confined to the Treppel factors and explained that considering a stockholder’s need to sue outside Delaware does not improperly require a commitment to the ends of the inspection.

Practice impact

The order confirms broad discretion to condition inspection based on case-specific facts. For inspection counsel, the stockholder’s need to litigate outside Delaware is a permissible consideration rather than an inquiry foreclosed by Treppel.

Read the source →
Signal40

Walmart’s appointment requirements defeat mandatory-advancement claim

What happened

On Voluntary Final Adjudication under 10 Del. C. § 350, a Magistrate in Chancery granted defendants summary judgment and denied Jenisha Likansis’s motion in her mandatory-advancement dispute. Walmart’s bylaws required Board or CEO appointment, and defendants established that Likansis was not an officer of any entity at issue. The parties stipulated to accept the report as an opinion subject to the same appellate process and review as an opinion issued by the Court’s constitutional officers.

Practice impact

The governing appointment language controlled officer status, and the same mandatory-advancement rules applied to Walmart’s internal Walmart Connect division. The court treated a delegation-of-authority argument as waived.

Read the source →

Rulings Worth Knowing

Signal53

Missed audited-financials deadline put Cornice on inquiry notice

What happened

The Supreme Court affirmed dismissal of Cornice’s fraud claims against Joshua Silberstein as untimely because Thrasio’s failure to deliver contractually required audited financial statements put Cornice on inquiry notice by April 2021, if not sooner.

Practice impact

The Court did not decide whether either asserted tolling doctrine was properly invoked: both tolled limitations only until inquiry notice. The missed reporting deadline, particularly after evasions over financial disclosure, preceded the suit by more than three years.

Read the opinion →
Signal42

Founder’s side-letter confirmation did not guarantee company obligations

What happened

Chancery ruled for Fancurve founder Chris Chaney on Count IV because the Side Letter’s company obligations were not his personal guarantees and Greenfield proved no breach of Section 4.

Practice impact

The SAFE provisions likewise entitled investors to distributions from legally available Proceeds under the contractual waterfall, not guaranteed repayment of their investments. Remaining remedial and fee-shifting issues follow the default-judgment ruling against Fancurve, including a supplemental valuation of the SAFE waterfall.

Read the opinion →
Signal41

Seller’s gross-up did not cover shareholders’ liquidation taxes

What happened

After trial, the Superior Court rejected Longshot’s request for $1.4 million in additional gross-up damages from Quaker, finding that the MIPA’s definition covered Longshot alone and that neither breach nor damages was proven.

Practice impact

The court expected an anticipated post-closing liquidation adjustment to be referenced in the MIPA. Its separate damages analysis distinguished the non-party shareholders’ tax losses from injury to Longshot, attributing any seller injury to its decision to indemnify its owners.

Read the opinion →
Signal48

UPEPA defeats defamation crossclaim arising from litigation defenses

What happened

In Sand Park Capital v. Lyrix Holdings, the Superior Court granted Lyrix’s UPEPA motion against Diamantis’s defamation crossclaim, stayed his amendment motion, required a fee-and-expense award and denied punitive damages.

Practice impact

Reading the protected categories disjunctively, the court did not require a matter of public concern and rejected the commercial-speech exception for speech directed to an internal company dispute. The claim failed for lack of specificity and under the absolute litigation privilege, with the required fee award adding a financial consequence.

Read the source →
Signal70

Patent indemnity enforced; interest-on-interest recovery reversed

What happened

In Gendreau v. Movora, the Supreme Court upheld post-closing patent-indemnity coverage despite a willful-infringement finding, required inclusion of a $9.8 million license cost and full patent-litigation fees, and reversed prejudgment interest on loan-interest expense.

Practice impact

The decision enforces this MIPA’s allocation of liability, not a blanket rule validating indemnification for willful misconduct. It distinguishes covered patent-litigation fees from uncovered indemnification-enforcement fees and remands for recalculation without the impermissible double interest recovery.

Read the opinion →

Chancery Signal provides legal news, research, and informational content and does not provide legal advice.