CHANCERY SIGNAL
← ALL ISSUES
CHANCERY SIGNAL3 MIN READ

FRIDAY, OCTOBER 23, 2026

Cloudflare recapitalization enjoined despite defendants’ Section 144 statutory victories

Committee good faith remains a potential obstacle to safe-harbor protection, alongside rulings on employee forum clauses, earnouts and LLC contractual rights.

The Signal

Signal89

Cloudflare preliminary relief turns on committee good faith

What happened

In its October 16 opinion in In re Cloudflare, Inc. Stockholder Litigation, Chancery granted preliminary relief preventing the recapitalization from closing pending post-trial disposition. Defendants prevailed on every statutory issue, including the inapplicability of the Injunction Exclusion and a clear-and-convincing trial burden for challenging committee members’ disinterestedness. Plaintiffs nevertheless showed a reasonable probability of defeating the General Controller Safe Harbor over committee good faith and, without that protection, succeeding under entire fairness.

Practice impact

The ruling distinguishes the statutory treatment of disinterestedness from the separate question whether the committee acted in good faith; it does not finally resolve the latter. What to watch: defendants’ election, due within ten days of the opinion, whether to pursue a prompt trial limited to satisfaction of the committee-approval path.

Read the opinion →
Signal57

Equity ownership does not prevent employee treatment in forum-clause dispute

What happened

In Aprio Advisory Group LLC v. Alexeev on October 16, Chancery treated an equity holder as functionally an employee who signed the challenged agreement as a condition of employment. The court held that a California statute made the Delaware forum and law provisions voidable at his election, which he exercised through his personal-jurisdiction challenge. It dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction.

Practice impact

Equity ownership alone did not control: Alexeev lacked the rights associated with equity partnership, and the court concluded that California had a materially greater interest. The decision reached only personal jurisdiction, not the enforceability of the covenants themselves.

Read the opinion →

Rulings Worth Knowing

Signal63

Buyer projections support earnout ripeness at the pleading stage

What happened

In Flannery v. London Stock Exchange Group on October 16, Chancery denied dismissal of parallel fraud and contract claims, finding the earnout claim ripe under VT’s framework and LSEG’s adoption of the merger agreement reasonably conceivable.

Practice impact

Defendants’ own projections demonstrated that the milestones were reasonably likely not to be achieved. The adoption finding remains a pleading-stage determination, and the court left interpretation of the commercially reasonable efforts clause for later proceedings.

Read the opinion →
Signal48

Invalid forced redemption warrants restoration and contractual extensions

What happened

In Techno-X USA Inc. v. Spartan Forge LLC on October 15, Chancery held the minority investor’s termination and redemption invalid and equitably extended the alignment-meeting period by 694 days and the services-agreement deadline to 60 days after entry of an implementing order.

Practice impact

The court found damages inadequate to remedy deprivation of the investor’s bargained-for rights, but rejected a new two-year exclusivity restriction and an extra-contractual blocking right. An implementing order is to follow, with remaining counterclaims reserved for phase two.

Read the opinion →
Signal54

Treppel factors do not exhaust inspection forum-restriction inquiry

What happened

In the Wong Leung trust’s Amazon inspection appeal on October 13, the Supreme Court affirmed by order and rejected an inquiry confined exclusively to Treppel’s factors when conditioning inspection on a forum restriction.

Practice impact

Courts retain broad discretion to consider case-specific facts, including a stockholder’s need to sue outside Delaware. Considering that need does not improperly require the stockholder to commit to the ends of its inspection.

Read the source →
Signal70

Patent indemnity covers post-closing losses, but not enforcement fees

What happened

In Gendreau v. Movora on September 24, the Supreme Court upheld this MIPA’s post-closing patent-indemnity coverage despite a willful-infringement finding, denied enforcement fees and reversed prejudgment interest on loan-interest expense as double recovery.

Practice impact

The decision enforces the agreement’s particular allocation of liability, not a blanket rule validating indemnities for willful misconduct. On remand, the judgment must include the $9.8 million license cost and full patent-litigation fees while excluding prejudgment interest on loan-interest expense.

Read the opinion →
Signal43

Purchase-only offer does not trigger two-way LLC buy/sell mechanism

What happened

In Blue Fire Capital LLC v. Lindeman on October 16, Chancery held that neither equal member was bound to sell because the initial purchase-only letter did not satisfy Section 9.12 and the response was a rejection and counteroffer.

Practice impact

Intent did not substitute for the required offer both to sell and to purchase, and the release terms foreclosed an implied offer to sell. The specified judgments did not encompass the derivative fiduciary duty claim.

Read the opinion →

Chancery Signal provides legal news, research, and informational content and does not provide legal advice.