CHANCERY SIGNAL
← ALL ISSUES
CHANCERY SIGNAL2 MIN READ

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 27, 2026

Supreme Court affirms dismissal where Oklahoma law defeats Delaware forum clause

Also in this issue: committee good faith under Section 144 and rulings on earnouts, minority-investor remedies and inspection restrictions.

The Signal

Signal74

Oklahoma law defeats Delaware forum clause as sole jurisdictional basis

What happened

On October 26, the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed dismissal of GI DI Rushmore Parent LP v. Stoops for lack of personal jurisdiction and denial of a preliminary injunction. The Court treated the forum-clause dispute as intra-corporate rather than an internal-affairs claim and applied a choice-of-law analysis. Oklahoma law governed and rendered the clause unenforceable because the parties had not specifically negotiated or discussed it.

Practice impact

A Delaware forum clause in an incentive-unit arrangement does not necessarily secure Delaware jurisdiction: here, it was the sole asserted jurisdictional basis, and its enforceability depended on Oklahoma law. The Court also explained that case law, not only statutes, can embody a fundamental policy. It did not decide whether Delaware law would enforce the clause.

Read the source →
Signal89

Doubts about committee good faith support preliminary relief despite Section 144 statutory victories

What happened

In its October 16 Cloudflare opinion, Chancery granted preliminary injunctive relief against the recapitalization even though defendants prevailed on every statutory issue under the 2025 Section 144 framework. Plaintiffs showed a reasonable probability of defeating the General Controller Safe Harbor based on the possibility that the committee did not act in good faith and, with that protection negated, a reasonable probability of success under entire fairness. The court stated that an injunction would prevent closing pending post-trial disposition.

Practice impact

The statutory rulings favor defendants: the Injunction Exclusion does not apply, and the heightened presumption requires clear-and-convincing proof at trial that committee members were not disinterested. Committee good faith nevertheless remains a separate potential obstacle to safe-harbor protection. The preliminary ruling does not finally resolve that issue.

Read the opinion →

Rulings Worth Knowing

Signal63

MayStreet earnout claim is ripe; parent adoption remains reasonably conceivable

What happened

In Flannery v. London Stock Exchange Group, Chancery denied dismissal on October 16, allowing parallel fraud and contract claims and finding both earnout ripeness under VT's framework and reasonably conceivable adoption of the merger agreement by LSEG.

Practice impact

Defendants' own projections supported the finding that the milestones were reasonably likely not to be achieved, while public acquisition statements bore on the adoption argument. The court left interpretation of the commercially reasonable efforts clause for later proceedings and cautioned that not every wholly owned subsidiary's agreement contemplates parent approval.

Read the opinion →
Signal48

Invalid forced redemption supports equitable extensions, not new blocking rights

What happened

In Techno-X v. Spartan Forge on October 15, Chancery held the minority investor entitled to have its termination and redemption set aside and extended specified contractual periods after finding exclusivity and consent breaches.

Practice impact

The court found damages inadequate and extended the alignment-meeting period by 694 days and the services-agreement deadline to 60 days after entry of an implementing order. It nevertheless rejected a new two-year exclusivity restriction and an extra-contractual transaction blocking right; remaining counterclaims await phase two.

Read the opinion →
Signal54

Treppel factors do not exhaust inspection forum-restriction inquiry

What happened

In the Wong Leung Trust's inspection dispute with Amazon, the Supreme Court affirmed on October 13 and rejected an argument that courts must confine inspection forum restrictions to the Treppel factors.

Practice impact

Courts retain broad discretion to impose conditions based on case-specific facts, including a stockholder's need to sue outside Delaware. Considering that need does not improperly require the stockholder to commit to the ends of its inspection.

Read the source →

Chancery Signal provides legal news, research, and informational content and does not provide legal advice.